Saturday, May 14, 2011

Why I don't respect most anti-theists.

You may have noticed from my previous postings that I have very little respect for most anti-theists.  Occasionally I come across anti-theists that I can respect, but they are generally few and far between.  Conversely, most of the theists I come across are very respectable people and only occasionally do I find theists that worthy of real contempt.

Strangely enough, I attribute this to religion.  Most theists learn at a very early age that if they want to follow some religion, they are going to come across people with different religions.  If they want to be respected enough to be allowed to believe what they want, they need to be respectful of others and allow them to believe what they want.

The anti-theists on the other hand don’t think they follow any religion.  By definition, anti-theism is a position that is opposed to theism and they all seem to be sure that theism is a religion so there is no way that they could be following something they are opposed to.

What the anti-theists fail to see is that a religion is nothing more than a way of running one’s life based on a faith.  A faith is nothing more than holding one or more beliefs.  And a belief is holding some unproven idea as true without the evidence to support that position.

Placed in a mathematical context, a belief is some assumption, being held as true for the sake of reasoning.  There is nothing wrong with it, but for the anti-theists, when this is done in a religious context it is faith and it is bad.  But if the same thing is done in science it is sound logical reasoning and is good.

It all sounds like the actual correct answer to the question: “How many angels can dance on the head of a pin”. Which of course is: “Whatever number makes my argument sound stronger”.

Theists might try to evangelize me, but they stop pretty quickly to avoid me doing the same thing back to them. I have no problem being as irritating to them as they are to me.  This tit for tat type of response seems to quickly settle down to a position of mutually disagreeing with each other’s position, but with respect for each others right to think what they want.

Anti-theists on the other hand are quite different.  They seem to want to play an “I’m superior to you” type of position.  If you don’t agree with their positions, they begin to sling insults and logical fallacies your way.  If you respond in kind, it quickly turns into a childish “Whose daddy’s dick is bigger” type of argument.

The main difference is that only a small number of theists will actually resort to such childish tactics.  Most of them, once they realize they can’t convert you to their position, will at least have the decency to allow you to believe the way you want to.

On the other hand, most of the anti-theists will actually resort to such tactics as their primary means to push their agenda.  It’s much less common for the anti-theists to realize they have picked a loosing battle, give up and simply get on with life.

I suspect this is due to how most anti-theists come into existence.  For the vast majority of them, they started out as theists.  At some point in time, something happened that that destroyed their faith.  It doesn’t seem to matter if it was something they felt was right was condemned by their religion, they where treated unfairly, or they logically deduced how wrong their faith was.

One way or another they got the idea that theism was wrong and now they are against it.  Hence the reason I call them anti-theists.  They are specifically about being opposed to theism.  For many of them, this amounts to throwing their lot in with what they see as the strongest position opposing religion which of course is science.

The reality is that science is totally separate from religion and there is not a single place where the two schools of thought overlap.  Sure there are idiot theists that try to use science to promote their positions, but even most theists consider those idiots to be whack jobs.

However, in the anti-theist camps, the norm seem to be people that think science is a reasonable way to show the theists are wrong.  Problem is, without evidence, science says nothing about the correctness or wrongness of any position.  It is simply unscientific to talk about something without evidence, yet that doesn’t stop the anti-theists from claiming rational thought is a good tool to refute theism.

You will notice a distinct push, especially by the most extreme anti-theists, to take on a position known as scientism.  It is a position that only science can be used to answer questions, and includes a distinct tendency to ridicule non-scientific arguments. 

It appears to be a kind of delusions of grandeur.  The vast majority of the things people talk about are non-scientific so therefore they are unimportant.  On the other hand, only a small elite group of intelligent people are qualified to talk about the really important things.  The delusion is that if this “real important” stuff was actually so important, more people would be talking about it.

It’s almost like an upper classman, ridiculing as lower classman for not knowing something.  It can only be described as a kind of undue arrogance.  What makes the arrogance worse, it that it leads the anti-theists to have an over inflated confidence in the soundness of their position.

The reality is when it comes to a question of the existence of a god; there is no evidence one way or another.  To claim that science can shed any light on the issue is either ignorant of what science is, or a down right dishonest attempt to baffle their opponent with scientific sounding bullshit.

So the school of hard knocks has taught me that to start with theists should be given the benefit of the doubt and be respected until they show they don’t deserve it.  On the other hand anti-theists need to earn their respect.

As an atheist, I don’t believe a god exists and I don’t believe a god doesn’t exist.  From my standpoint, the only thing wrong is the declaration that either position is wrong.  What decides the question of the level of respect I will give is the level of respect I receive.

Monday, May 9, 2011

Evolution and Origins of Life

So how many times have you heard an anti-theist talk about how stupid the theists are when they talk about both evolution and the origins of life?  The argument is generally stated as “evolution doesn’t speak to the question of the origins of life”.

While this may be true, the theists where never talking about it in that way.  Contrary to the popular anti-theistic belief it is quite possible to talk about a scientific subject and just not restrict oneself to scientific views.  It may not be the stuff of a scientific paper, but then again neither is most of the conversations in this world.

Many anti-theists try to claim that the only thing that is real is what science defines as real.  However, ever since the empiricist movement from several hundred years ago, it has been quite clear that what is real is not defined by science.  Some choose to believe what science defines as real actually is the same as reality, but that is only a belief.

What science does do is define what is acceptable in a scientific conversation.  It sets guidelines of what can be considered evidence and limits thinking to the verifiable conditions that it was founded on.

But thinking that evolution can only be thought of in a scientific context, is a childish bigoted view that presupposes that only science is worthy of conversation.  This is the general starting point for what is known as scientism.  The religion of believing science is the only valid way to describe the universe.

While many of the theists can’t describe why they want to talk about evolution and origins at the same time doesn’t mean they are wrong to do so.  In fact I see it as actually a very good sign of the theists having a strong intuitive understanding of some of the flaws in evolution.

When someone says that they don’t accept evolution, there are at least two possible meanings of what they are saying.  On one hand they could be saying they reject everything stated in the theory.  But on the other hand they could simply be saying that they don’t accept ALL of evolution.  The insane anti-theists only ever hear the first one and don’t bother to ask before they start into their normal insult and logical fallacy side show acts.

So lets say we have a theist or an atheist (which of course if not an anti-theist), and they don’t accept evolution.  They would agree that the parts that can be demonstrated in solid scientific experiments are acceptable and they don’t have a problem with those parts.

This most likely means they don’t have a problem with modern generics.  If you can do a test in a lab over and over again, varying the conditions, and observing the outcomes, that’s pretty solid evidence and accepting what is found is not all that hard.

But consider archeology.  All you can do is dig up stuff and attempt to classify it into your favorite categories.  The older and older the things you dig up are, the less likely there is that you could get any genetic material for comparison.  And as the geologists are so fond of saying, only some environments are conducive to the creation of fossils.
So archeology gives us by definition a VERY incomplete view of what was alive at some point in time. The further back in time we go the less information we can actually glean from what we find. Not only are a small number of the members of a species fossilized, a potentially large number of species could have existed in an environment that didn’t produce fossils.

Also notice that there is no real experimentation.  Nobody has buried something and dug it up millions of years later to see how it was changed.  Simply looking at the results without knowing the exact initial conditions, is not an experiment.  It’s just digging up pretty artifacts and organizing them in your display box.

So how does this relate to evolution and the origins of life?

One of the core concepts of evolution is the tree of life otherwise know as the common ancestor theory.  This theory in its most extreme form postulates that all life on earth is related genetically and the process of natural selection accounts for all the diversity of life.

Here is where the origin question enters the picture.  Was there a single unique instance where life began (however it happened) or where there many instances where matter somehow managed to get organized in such a way to make the jump from not life to life?

Of course the theists say that a god did it once a long time ago. The anti-theists, just the same, say it also happened one time a long time ago.  But consider the possibility that life actually got started many times.  If this was the case, not all life is related in a parent/child relationship.  Different life forms could have formed totally independently of each other and survived until today meaning there are life forms that don’t have a common ancestor between them.

Simply talking the scientific side, going back in time one would expect to life to get simpler and simpler.  The earliest forms of life would most likely be very simple single cell organisms. As you get closer and closer to this postulated first life form, we would also expect that the genetic sequences used for reproduction would also be simpler and simpler.

No matter how you slice it, simpler and simpler genetic sequences mean fewer and less complicated proteins could have formed.  This would mean the basic chemistry of life would have to get simpler the further you went back in time.  It is easy to infer that as the chemistry gets simpler, the likelihood of it happening goes up.

So we are on a trajectory of life becoming simpler and the chances of those chemical reactions randomly happening increasing as we go.  At some point, we would have to reach a point where the chemical reactions are so commonplace that they happen in many places at many times.

For the single occurrence model to be correct, life would need to have started late in this sequence of events.  The multiple occurrence models favor an earlier start to life.  And this brings us to the real question.  What is your definition of life?

There is no generally accepted definition of the term.  It’s kind of like the definition for pornography.  “I don’t know what it is, but I know it when I see it”.

With so many possible definitions, all the factions are free to choose whatever definition they want.  Simply put, this means everyone is right or everyone is wrong.  Since some of the positions are diametrically opposed, it’s not actually possible for everybody to be right so the only sane answer is that everybody is wrong including the scientismistic (is that a word) fans of evolution.

This really goes to the question of how you would tell the difference between to the two positions.  The ignostic position is that like the question of the existence of a god, the question of the validity of the common ancestor theory is meaningless until you define precisely what you mean with the term “life”.

So here are a few questions that need to be answered first:

1.      What is the minimal genetic sequence(s) that qualifies as a life form?
2.      Starting with that, what are the sequences of mutations that lead to all modern life forms?
3.      What additional supporting chemistry needs to be in place within this entity to qualify as an original life form?
4.      What are the minimal environmental conditions needed around the life form for it to survive?
5.      What does this original life form consume and secrete?

Until there are accepted definitions for at least some of these questions, arguing over the question of single or multiple occurrences of life starting is just another example of arguing the number of angels that can dance of the head of a pin.

It also means that theistic questions about how evolution and the origins of life are related are well founded.  In addition it means that anti-theists that say evolution doesn’t speak to the origins of life, while being scientifically correct, are simply being intellectually dishonest.

Unless you can precisely define what life is, any claim that there are common ancestors between all species is just a religious dogma. To think it isn’t, is precisely to be an anti-theist (a person with a religion that hates different religions).

Friday, May 6, 2011

Math is not a subset of science, math is a tool used by science

It really surprises me that there is a need for this posting, but again and again I see scientism fans claiming that math is a subset of science or some other such nonsense.  It seems like what they are just trying to make science seem stronger than it actually is.

To begin with, math was invented literally thousands of years before the idea of science was even conceived.  There is solid evidence of the use of mathematic way back into ancient times.  In contrast science, at best, is only a few hundred years old.

In general, the longer some subject is around the broader and more evolved we would expect that subject to be.  Considering that math has been around for much longer than science we would expect math to be much more intricate than science and this is exactly what we find.

The diversity of subjects that fall into a math category is simply enormous. If you can think of a subject that involves using numbers or equations to solve a problem, there most likely has been something written about it.

Science on the other hand is comparatively quite limited.  To argue otherwise would be to claim that in a few hundred years, science has been able to amass more information than thousands of years of math did.  This is a simple cardinality argument.  If you want to play asshole, given that mathematics has named all the integer values and that set is infinite, there are simply names for more things in mathematics that science can ever have.

But playing whose daddy has the bigger dick games is not really telling of much more than the opinions of the various pundits.  But a differentiation between math and science can be made on a much more fundamental level.  And this appears to be where many scientism fans fail because they don’t have a basic understanding of some of the fundamentals of mathematics.

At their cores mathematics and science are fundamentally different.  Science is based on the idea that for something to be valid it must be a falsifiable idea.  The idea must be subject to being challenged and there must be a way for that challenge to be tested. Mathematics on the other hand is based on ideas that are not falsifiable (also known as proven).  For math the real significance of an idea is when it is shown that it is correct and can never again be challenged.

In fact if you really push a real degreed scientist to show some scientific idea is proven, he will correct you with a statement saying that nothing in science is proven correct.  The best science can do is prove something is wrong.

Any idea in science is subject to being changed when new evidence is presented.  However, in math, once a theory has been proven, it is not possible for new evidence to be presented.  In fact this gets at exactly what a mathematical proof actually is and why the idea of a scientific proof is an oxymoron.

In both science and math, we have what is known as a hypothesis.  This can be best described as a half baked idea.  It’s generally vague, all the consequences of the idea have not been worked out, and nobody would ever claim that it is in any way proven.

In both fields, once all the consequences of the hypothesis are worked out and we can show that everything is consistent, we reach the level of a theory (a fully baked idea).  Notice that at this level, if we assume the theory is correct, we can be assured that everything works and any possible result the theory produces makes sense.

In science the best we can do is begin to look for evidence that a theory is not correct.  While evidence that doesn’t contradict some theory is important, by far, evidence that refutes a theory is much more important because it definitively shows that the theory is wrong.  But science never achieves a level of certainty where it is legitimate to claim the theory if correct.  The best science can do is show that some theory has not been proven wrong.

However, in math, reaching the level of a theory starts the process of trying to prove the theory.  While this process may have similarities to the experimental process in science the outcomes are considerably different.

In mathematics, the process of proving a theory is a process where all possible opposing ideas are ruled out leaving the theory as the only possible solution.  Because all the alternative ideas have been ruled out, the level of certainty of the theory being correct is enormously larger than what science achieves with its experimentation. In fact when math does succeed in proving a theory, we no longer call it a theory and start calling it a law or a fact to differentiate it from a theory which is by definition unproven.

Because of the rigors of being forced to find all alternative ideas and then rule each and every one out, mathematics guarantees that a proven theory can never be disproven.  Put in scientific terms, that means the idea is no longer falsifiable and therefore it is now unscientific. 

If math was a part of science, every time it accomplished its goals, another piece of science would suddenly become an invalid idea.  While math is a useful tool to science, it is extremely misguided to think that math is a subset of science.  It’s not misguided to think that math is a subset of the tools that are at science’s disposal.

But to think math is a subset of science is a kin to thinking a hammer is a subset of a carpenter.  At best to make that argument you would have to be rather naive.  At worst, it would be a blatant attempt to raise the level of importance of the hammer to the carpenter.

Of course, a carpenter knows what a hammer is good for, doesn’t need a pep-rally on the virtues of the hammer, and surely doesn’t argue that he’s better than everyone because he uses a hammer.  Any fool can use a hammer.

If only seems to be the anti-theistic wacko’s, trying to muster some additional credibility that make the argument that math is a part of science.  They are obviously only trying to lend the certainty levels found in math to science so they appear to have a better alternative to the theists they seem to hate.

Saturday, April 23, 2011

The Anti-Theist Creation Myth; The Big Bang.

While the Christians have their Genesis creation myth, the anti-theist crowd has their own creation myth in the form of the Big Bang theory.  If you listen to the anti-theists they would have you believe the theory is established scientific fact just the same as the Christians would claim the Genesis story is established fact.

In reality the Big Bang theory has absolutely no evidence to support it just as the Genesis story has no evidence.  Now of course the anti-theists will start claiming that things like relativity, Hubble’s law, and cosmic microwave background radiation (CMBR) are evidence of the correctness of the Big Bang theory.  But are they?

Most of this claim there is evidence comes from the observation of the Doppler affect and the observation that light coming from distant sources appears shifted in frequency.  The assumption is that this entire shift in frequency is caused by the Doppler affect.  However, what evidence is there that this is actually so.  Simply put none.

First they assume that light travels unchanged, at a constant speed, for the entirety of its journey from its source to here on earth where we see it.  But what evidence is there for that?  The furthest that humans have ever transmitted an EM signal is only about 0.002 light years.  These signals are the transmissions from the Voyager space craft.  So would someone please explain to me how a transmission of such a short length provides any evidence of things working the same way over distances that are billions of times longer?

The Quantum Theory fans would have you believe that the laws of physics are quite different on extremely small scales, so why should we believe they are the same on extremely large scales?  At least the quantum fans have some evidence to support their claim.

It is interesting that part of Planck’s kicking off the quantum theory was the relationship between frequency and energy.  The higher the frequency of the light, we find the higher the energy level of the light. In general, the light coming from distant objects is red shifted to a lower energy level.  The objects further away have a greater red shift.

If light simply lost a little energy during its long travel, we would see what would look like a Doppler shift when we received the light.  All it would take is slight drag or loss of energy for this effect to be real.  In addition, there would be no way for us to find this experimentally because we cannot transmit and receive light over any significant distance.

Given that some nearby galaxies have a blue shift; it’s not hard to imagine that both a Doppler shift and a slight drag could both be real phenomenon.  All observations that we would have made are still valid, only the interpretation of those observations would change.

Most importantly, it would mean that the universe is not expanding.  And therefore since it’s not, there is no reason to believe that all the matter used to be closer together, so there is no evidence that a big bang happened.

Recently, a real kink in the big bang theory has come to light (pun intended).  Measurements of the red shift from various objects have shown that the rate at which the universe is supposes to be expanding is accelerating.  But this is a problem in itself.

According the conservation of energy laws, no new energy is supposes to be created.  However to accelerate, you must add energy to the objects that are accelerating.  So where is new energy coming from?  If the universe is accelerating its expansion must be being caused by additional energy that was not present in the past, or it is being released from someplace where it has been locked up for the entire past of the universe.

Interestingly enough, if the universe was simply cooling down and becoming denser, you might expect that the drag it produces on light would increase.  A simple explanation might be that over time the existing energy is getting more and more evenly distributed across the universe.  As energy gets more evenly distributed the amount of energy that light has to interact with on its long journey increases.  So, this would cause the amount of drag and therefore red shift to increase.  This would look like the rate of expansion is increasing when viewed from here on Earth.

About this time the anti-theists will start so say, “You don’t have any evidence for this”.  The appropriate response, “Well you don’t have any evidence for your position either”.  At which point they generally bring up cosmic microwave background radiation (CMBR).  They generally ask well how do you explain CMBR?  Well actually quite easily. 

If light is loosing energy as it travels, CMBR is simply light from much further away that has been red shifted down into the microwave range.  At this point the smarter ones go after "but we have no evidence the universe is that large".  This of course leads to the question of the sensitivity of the instruments being used to see distant objects.

Ever noticed that as equipment has been getting more and more sensitive, the estimated size of the universe has been getting bigger?  The simple reality is that to focus light that has longer and longer wavelength (and therefore smaller and smaller frequency) you need a bigger and bigger detector.

Once you have instruments the size of the diameter of the Earth or even the diameter of the Earth’s orbit you MIGHT be able to claim you are actually seeing to the edge of the universe, but any estimate that you are making now, is just you trying to make up a theory that fits the observations you do have.

Give me 1000 years of increases in the sensitivity of detecting equipment without seeing anything further away and you may have some evidence.  But claiming there is nothing out there because you haven’t seen it, is just intellectual dishonesty.

The main point of this post was to highlight the fact that given any set of observations it quite easy to come up with alternative explanations that fit those observations perfectly.  To choose one particular interpretation and demand that others agree with it is exactly why so many anti-theists are simply pushing their flavor of religion on others.

Anybody can write something in a book and get some group of people to believe it.  After a while you get a clergy of people that have studied the book and are somehow qualified to tell others what it means.  It doesn’t matter if it religion or science, the same thing is being done.

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Belief in relativity, IS just another religion.

If you listen to many anti-theists, you will no doubt have come across their tendency to try and use the scientific method as a justification of their ideas.  It generally is presented that verifiable evidence is preferable to unverifiable evidence.  Leaving a side the obvious question of the validity of only considering verifiable evidence, this approach is misguided mostly by the fact that there are an awful lot of cases in science where the established explanation is based on unverified assumptions that have no evidence to support them.

If you are going to require that when an explanation is formulated, only verifiable evidence is allowed to be considered, that leaves you will a big logical problem when the final explanation contains ideas that have never been verified with any experiment.

The best known and most misunderstood example of this is the theory of relativity.  If you ask most people if they think that relativity is a correct, they will say yes.  But if you ask them to explain the theory, very few, even college professors, are able to explain the theory in an adequate way.

The reality is that with some high school level mathematics training, relativity is an extremely simple idea.  It is also quite easy to understand where the theory is useful and where people use it incorrectly.  But a real good question is just how verified is the theory?

Proponents of the theory will claim that it's been verified when actuality, even more than 100 years after it was published, its core concepts have never been tested.  Several tangential aspects of the theory have been verified, but they only show that theory has not been proven wrong.  They are a far cry from showing that the theory is correct.

One thing, most people fail to understand is that there are entire families of theories that predict exactly the same thing relativity does.  Every single observation ever made is equally well explained by those theories as it is by relativity. But if you ask people about WHY relativity is better than those alternative theories, there are even less people that can give that answer than there are people that can explain the basics of relativity itself.

So you may be asking, what is unverified.  Simply put the two postulates that form the basis of the whole theory.  The easiest one to deal with is the invariance of the speed of light. The issue has to do with exactly how you measure that speed.  Basically this can be done one of two ways.

The first way is to setup a light and a clock at one end of some distance, and put a mirror at the other end.  You turn on the light and measure the time it takes for the light to travel to the mirror and return.  This is known as the two way speed of light.

The other way, known as the one way speed of light, is where there are two points at some distance apart that each have clocks that have been synchronized so the time difference for light to travel the distance can be measured.

You would have to be an idiot to not realize that a more complicated test with two clocks that have to be synchronized is less precise than the single clock test.  A major assumption that the two clocks run at the same speed has to be added for the two clock model to hold any validity.  We already know that where you are can absolutely affect the speed a clock runs.

Simply take two identical atomic clocks and place one on the ground floor of a tall building and place the other one on the top floor.  They actually run at different speeds.  This fact is why the GPS system must account for the difference in clock rates in orbit and on the ground.

The relativity proponents will claim that the issue is because of the gravitational field and special relativity does not account for it.  But where exactly have they performed any experiments that are free of any gravitational field?

So we know that clocks DON'T always run at the same speed and we don't have a lab to perform the tests outside of a gravitational field.  So how is the two clock method anything more than being told we should ignore the man behind the curtain?  No experiment is ever actually performed that meets the requirements, and any experiment that is performed must take into account they fact the assumption of the clocks working at the same rate is wrong.

So if we turn our attention to the two way, one clock test, we get around the synchronization and clock rate problems.  But all of a sudden relativity is NOT so assured any more.  Some simple calculations show that whether the speed of light is constant or the speed of light is variable, all possible observations are exactly the same.

The only serious argument that has been made is one that Ritz and deSitter had years ago.  deSitter argued that if light was not constant in speed the observed orbits of binary star systems would be distorted.  But that argument adds another big assumption.  The assumption is that the speed of light is constant over the whole distance regardless of the length of that distance.

Given that today, the farthest any EM signal has been transmitted and received is about 0.002 light years.  That's quite a bit away from being anything near the distance between star systems.  To assert that the speed of light is constant of such a large distance is nothing more than a guess.  Once again no experiment has ever verified the assumption.

So we are left with a situation where the only reliable test is over a very short distance using a method that doesn't rule out the possibility of the assumption being wrong.  So given no experiment has been performed using either of the methods that is not open to serious questions, how can anybody claim relativity is right or wrong?  Simply put there is no verifiable evidence for either position.

So how exactly is belief in relativity any different than a belief in a religion?

Tuesday, April 5, 2011

If they use the word objective, they are religious kooks, unless they are talking about linguistics.

We have all heard both the theists and anti-theists talk about objective versus subjective this or that.  The theists have their objective morality and the anti-theists have their objective reality.  They are both doing the same thing.  They are using the linguistic concepts of the subjective and objective parts of speech to try and add some level of credibility to their statements

For anybody that has studied linguistics, the subjective part represents the entity performing the action, the verb part represents the action, and the objective part represent what is being acted on.  So the use of the term objective outside of linguistics is just an attempt to make something sound independent of the subjective part of the statement. This is an obvious attempt to make it sound immune to personal biases.

The theists use this to assert that morality is completely independent of how somebody thinks about it.  The anti-theists use it to assert that reality is independent of how anybody thinks about it.  But when you start to look at it from this perspective and how they justify this increased level of independence, you quickly find that there is no real basis for the assertion.  You begin to see that all the adjective is being used for is to make the argument SOUND more convincing than it really is.

The question boils down to what is the difference between subjective and objective outside of linguistics.  The simplest way I can come up with to describe it is that subjective refers to cases where a mind is involved and objective is when a mind is not involved.  The theists suggest that their morality would exist regardless of the existence of people and the anti-theists suggest the universe would exist without the existence of people.

But doesn't that beg the question: How could you possibly know anything for certain about a place or time that cannot by definition have anybody experiencing it? Without anybody there to verify the assertion, any claim to having evidence to support the position must be a bold faced lie. The theists try to use the excuse of divine inspiration and the anti-theists try to use the claim that processes worked the same in the past as they do today.

But look closely at those excuses.  How could anybody ever show that either of those is more valid than an assertion of exactly the opposite?  Basically the theists are claiming divine inspiration must have happened because we have their objective morality.  And the anti-theists are claiming that processes must be the same in the past because of what they see now. So how is it with absolutely no evidence, either position is anything but a personal guess?

Both are a bit of trickery known as a logical implication.  If you have studied logic, you will know that an implication is a two input Boolean function where one input is the premise and the other is what is being tested.  The truth table for this function is that when the premise is true, the output follows the value of what is being tested.  However, when the premises is false the output is ALWAYS true.

For example, it the premise is that "Guns kill people" it makes sense to ban guns.  But if the reality is that actually "People kill people" then the original argument is just a ruse to get you to agree with the logic.  If the premise is true the output is meaningful, but if the premise is false the output is meaninglessly always the same. 

So if the premise is wrong, the use of a logical argument has absolutely no power to shed any light on the question.  What the person making the argument was doing was simply being intellectually dishonest.  Either that, or they where just plain stupid, in which case there is even less reason to agree with their argument.

In either case, this amounts to a need for a major red flag to be raised whenever someone uses the word objective in any argument they make.  At a bare minimum it is an indication that you need to be looking VERY closely at any assumptions or premises that might be proposed.  For if you don't accept the premises they are presenting, their argument is even less valuable than to have not made the argument to begin with.

In addition, if you are planning on using the word objective in your argument, you need to be very careful and get your opponent to stipulate to your assumptions before you make the argument.  Otherwise your opponent will simply dismiss your argument on the grounds that you are dishonest or that you are stupid

Saturday, March 26, 2011

An anti-theist is NOT an atheist.

I seem to run into a lot of people that claim they are atheists, but when you listen to what they are saying you find that they are not atheists, they are anti-theists.  Now according to them, anti-theism is just a more activist version of atheism.  This post to to hightlight why this is not true and try to explain why so many anti-theists want so badly to be classified as atheists.

The best way to describe this is a little story.  A theist walks up to an atheist and says "I believe I can fly".  The atheist (rightfully so) responds with "Show me some evidence".  After much arguing and no demonstration of this ability, the atheist says "I don't believe you can fly".  When this story is replayed between a theist and an anti-theist.  The only difference is the anti-theist says "I believe you cannot fly".  The anti-theist also generally goes on make comments describing how the theist is lying and how they are such a low life for making such claims.

Where the atheists simply says "I don't believe you" the anti-theist actively asserts that they not only don't believe the theists but that the theist is wrong for making the claims they make.  Both are rightfully using the lack of evidence as justification of their position.  However the anti-theist is taking it one step further and applying some kind of moral judgement on the theists.

This gets at the heart of the difference between atheists and anti-theists.  To a hard core atheist, there is no such thing as absolute good or evil.  Those concepts are nothing more than expressions of people's likes and dislikes.  To attempt to make them into something more than just personal opinions, is to do nothing more than raise one person's feelings of likes and dislikes to a level that is more important than other people's feelings.  This of course has the effect of downgrading someone else's feelings to point where they can be disregarded.

For an atheist, NOBODY'S feeling are more important than anybody elses.  There is no scale where somebody's feelings can be ranked as more virtuous than another's.  In fact, the act of blessing some people's feelings and supressing someone else's feelings is generally the cause of most of the inflicted harm that is perpetrated on people every day.

However, the anti-theist look at this entirely different.  They generally feel that theism has caused some kind of problem that they don't like and now feel justified to mock and insult the theists.  The most militant of the anti-theists will actually advocate penalizing the theists.

This can only be described as a kind of mental disease.  The theists are wrong because they want to force their beliefs on others, but somehow the anti-thists are right because they want to force their beliefs on others.  The theists are wrong for pushing their moral agenda, but the anti-theists are right because they are pushing their moral agenda.

An atheists sits back and says, "While it's not possible for both sides to be right about the existance of a god.  The other possible answer is that BOTH sides are wrong".  Unless you are an idiot and have not kept up with the advance in mathematics during the 20th century, you would know that there are situations where it is simply impossible to make a decision about which is the right answer.

So while there may be some truth to one or the other answer to the question of a god's existance, it is entirely possible that this is just one of those situations where it is not possible to choose.  In other words there may be some ultimate truth, but no human can EVER know the answer.  Therefore choosing to be on the side of believing a god exists or believing a god doesn't exist, is simply wrong on an fundamentally trivial basis.

If you pay attention, you will find that most anti-theists where at one time theists and "deconverted" as they call it to their anti-theism position.  This is actually a very interesting point.  The hard core theists attempts to push their moral position on others while the hard core anti-theists do the same thing.  They both follow the unethical position that they are right and the rest of the world should be forced to follow their kind of thinking.

Both positions are in sharp contrast to an atheist's position that NOBODY should be forced to believe or disbelieve anything.  Every person has the right to make up their own mind, and there is nothing wrong with choosing any possible alternative.  The only thing that could possible be a universally disliked thing is when someone else tries to force you to believe something you don't accept.  Or worse, when someone advocates penalizing someone for their bad thinking.

If you want a demonstration of the difference between an atheist and an anti-theist, make the following statement: "Atheism is just another religion".  An atheist will respond with sure why not, there is nothing wrong with religions.  An anti-theists on the other had will take great offense at that statement.  The anti-theists are so wrapped up in the ideal of how evil religion is and how wrong the theists are that they think it's an insult to claim such a blasphemy.

The anti-theists just like the theists, seem to be so unsure of their position that even the slightest hint that they may be wrong is unacceptable.  An atheist on the other hand makes no moral judgement about a person based on their beliefs.  For an atheist a preditor is not evil for killing Bambee, it's just feeding.

When the theists or anti-theists feel attacked they seem to identify with Bambee and consider the preditor is some kind of evil thing.  The atheist simply accepts them for what they are and defends themself.  No need to go out and hnut down those evil preditors and eradicate them or change them into something else.  All you need to do is protect yourself from them and the stupid people who don't, simply choose to be the preditor's next meal.

I suspect that most anti-theists at some level understand how closely they are related to the theists they hate so much.  They have a real fear of the same thing being in them that they see in those evil theists.  Because of this they want to classify themselves are atheists (without god) to make themselves feel more confortable with what they are esposing.

However, if you think there is something wrong with theists, atheists, or anti-theists you are NOT an atheist.  You are just a religious kook that is trying to use your personal view of religion to justify some crappy treatment of somebody you don't like.

Why don't you stop hating them for what they believe and hate them for being douche bags reguardless of what they believe.  Don't people get that atheism is without the existance or non-existance of a god.  It's simply without a god.  If your running around talking about how bad people are because of their belief in a god, you are most definitely WITH a god.  Just one you don't like.